Blog | Tomorrow's Technology Today

How Should an Insurance Agency Protect Client Data in Microsoft 365, Email, and Backups?

Written by Lisa Niekamp-Urwin | Nov 5, 2026, 2:00:00 PM

An insurance agency protects client data in Microsoft 365, email, and backups with 6 safeguards: multifactor authentication on every account, hardened email settings, encrypted devices that can be wiped remotely, a separate backup of Microsoft 365, immutable backups of critical systems, and restore tests on a fixed schedule. For a 10 to 50 person agency, all 6 are part of managed IT at $175 to $350 per user per month.

Here's the part many agencies miss: Microsoft keeps your email and files running, but keeping your data recoverable is your responsibility. Deleted mail, an overwritten folder, or a ransomware-encrypted OneDrive won't necessarily come back on its own. That's why the safeguards below come in layers.

The 6 Safeguards

1. Multifactor authentication on every account

A stolen password is the most common way into a Microsoft 365 account. Multifactor authentication should be required on every email account, not "most users," and turned on for admin and remote access too.

2. Hardened email settings

Microsoft 365 out of the box isn't locked down. We harden settings against the impersonation that leads to payment fraud, and our human-staffed Security Operations Center watches Microsoft 365 for signs an account has been taken over.

3. Encrypted devices that can be wiped remotely

Producers' laptops leave the office. Every device should have its drive encrypted, and you should be able to wipe a lost or stolen laptop remotely before it turns into a breach.

4. A separate backup of Microsoft 365

Email, OneDrive, and SharePoint should be backed up to a separate cloud backup service, outside Microsoft. Every agency we support gets Microsoft 365 backup.

5. Immutable backups of critical systems

Servers and computers running critical programs should be backed up to immutable storage, meaning backup copies that can't be altered or deleted, even by ransomware. Immutable backup is standard for every client we support.

6. Restore tests on a fixed schedule

A backup that completes isn't proof the data comes back. We run a full restore test of every backup every other week, with a screenshot of the restored system as proof, and an engineer reviews backup status every business morning.

The Backup Gap Most Agencies Don't Know About

SharePoint now lets you mark files as "archived" to save storage. Our backup platform can't back up or protect SharePoint files once they've been archived, and as of today the vendor has no plans to add that. We'd rather tell you than find out during a restore. If your agency archives SharePoint files, talk with us about how those records are kept and protected.

Ask any provider the same question: is there anything in our environment your backup can't reach? An honest answer is a good sign.

What Changes at 10, 25, and 50 Employees

  • 10-person agency, everything in Microsoft 365: the focus is multifactor authentication, email hardening, device encryption, and Microsoft 365 backup.
  • 25-person agency with a server or a second office: add immutable server backups and secure connections between offices.
  • 50-person agency with remote producers: add tighter admin controls and a formal process for removing a departing employee's access and wiping their devices.

5 Questions to Ask Your IT Provider

  1. Is Microsoft 365 backed up somewhere other than Microsoft?
  2. Are our backups immutable?
  3. When was our last restore test, and can I see the proof?
  4. If a producer's laptop is stolen today, can you wipe it?
  5. Is there anything your backup can't protect?

How We Set This Up for Agency Clients

During Great Start onboarding, we enforce multifactor authentication with advance notice to your staff, harden Microsoft 365, set up Microsoft 365 backup, and document every device. After that, the checks run on a schedule: backup status every business morning, restore tests every other week, and 24/7 monitoring through our Security Operations Center. These are also the controls your cyber insurance carrier asks about. See what it takes to qualify for or renew cyber insurance and the 7 layers of protection an agency actually needs.

Why Insurance Agencies Work With Tomorrow's Technology Today

  • Supporting independent insurance agencies since 2011, and local businesses for more than 20 years
  • Microsoft Partner, and one of the first providers in our region to move businesses to Microsoft 365, starting about 12 years ago
  • 24/7 managed detection and response and security awareness training included in every plan
  • Headquartered in St. Henry, Ohio, with an office in Fort Wayne; woman-owned and woman-led
  • Every technician is security-trained to CJIS standards and background-checked

See how we support independent insurance agencies across Ohio and Indiana.

Want to know where your client data stands? Book a 10-minute discovery call. Call us at (419) 678-2083 or visit www.TomTechToday.com/discoverycall to schedule yours.